Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Does Cloudy Water Bother Goldfish?
Forum > The Goldfish Topics > Goldfish Tanks > Water problems? Questions about water quality?
dollface
I'm really concerned about my goldfish, Zeebo, living in a cloudy tank. Does anyone know if it stresses them out or makes them unhappy?

I left school for the weekend but before I left on Friday I did a 30% water change, vaccuumed the gravel, added a second cartridge (my filter allows you to put 2 cartridges in at the same time), and put in a fish feeder that i've used before with no cloudiness problem. I normally do my water changes and vaccuuming 1x a week but I was on crutches and had to stretch it to 2 weeks. So I noticed a lot of stuff in the gravel when I was vaccuuming, and I was unable to get it all w/o taking out a lot of water.

So I left right after I did that, and returned on Sunday. My tank has been cloudy ever since. I tested the water and it's fine besides the pH is a bit off (6.0). I used a water clarifier and that did not work like it normally does with tank disturbances (ie: drunk people putting excessive fish food in the tank). I through out the used cartridges and replaced it with one new one. I purchased a little baggie at the store and filled it with carbon to put in the filter with the new cartridge... and it's still cloudy.

I even talked to a very knowledgeable man about my situation and he agrees that it is very mysterious. It seems like I can't do anything else to improve the cloudiness. I have a 20 gallon tank with one fancy fish, and a filter that pumps 30 gallons per hour. I hope the water will clear up on it's on and that my fish will be okay.

I feel so awful just seeing him swimming in it and there's nothing I can do. sad.gif ...sorry for the long post.
zildjian_4
QUOTE(dollface @ Apr 21 2008, 05:12 PM) *
I'm really concerned about my goldfish, Zeebo, living in a cloudy tank. Does anyone know if it stresses them out or makes them unhappy?

I left school for the weekend but before I left on Friday I did a 30% water change, vaccuumed the gravel, added a second cartridge (my filter allows you to put 2 cartridges in at the same time), and put in a fish feeder that i've used before with no cloudiness problem. I normally do my water changes and vaccuuming 1x a week but I was on crutches and had to stretch it to 2 weeks. So I noticed a lot of stuff in the gravel when I was vaccuuming, and I was unable to get it all w/o taking out a lot of water.

So I left right after I did that, and returned on Sunday. My tank has been cloudy ever since. I tested the water and it's fine besides the pH is a bit off (6.0). I used a water clarifier and that did not work like it normally does with tank disturbances (ie: drunk people putting excessive fish food in the tank). I through out the used cartridges and replaced it with one new one. I purchased a little baggie at the store and filled it with carbon to put in the filter with the new cartridge... and it's still cloudy.

I even talked to a very knowledgeable man about my situation and he agrees that it is very mysterious. It seems like I can't do anything else to improve the cloudiness. I have a 20 gallon tank with one fancy fish, and a filter that pumps 30 gallons per hour. I hope the water will clear up on it's on and that my fish will be okay.

I feel so awful just seeing him swimming in it and there's nothing I can do. sad.gif ...sorry for the long post.



if ur water test all comes up good, then ur pretty safe IMO. whats the temperature of the water? perhaps try some sort of live plant?hopefully some2 can answer ur question better than i, good luck!
Acupunk
6.0 is a very low pH -- dangerously so. I don't know what this has to do with the cloudiness, but it is probably an important clue. Hope someone more knowledgeable can help you out.
Jack of Hearts
QUOTE(dollface @ Apr 21 2008, 09:12 PM) *
I tested the water and it's fine besides the pH is a bit off (6.0). I used a water clarifier



It's certainly not fine. As Acupunk said, it is dangerously low. One step before a pH crash. Those water clarifier usually contain mild acid solution...the last thing you should be putting into an already mildly acidic tank.

The cloudiness could be a result of a bacteria bloom. However I would put that on the backburner for a second and deal with the low pH issue immediately.
dollface
QUOTE(Jack of Hearts @ Apr 21 2008, 10:52 PM) *
QUOTE(dollface @ Apr 21 2008, 09:12 PM) *
I tested the water and it's fine besides the pH is a bit off (6.0). I used a water clarifier



It's certainly not fine. As Acupunk said, it is dangerously low. One step before a pH crash. Those water clarifier usually contain mild acid solution...the last thing you should be putting into an already mildly acidic tank.

The cloudiness could be a result of a bacteria bloom. However I would put that on the backburner for a second and deal with the low pH issue immediately.


How do I deal with a low pH or a bacteria bloom?
Fishy Fish
Hi DollFace - what a cute name! biggrin.gif

At 6.0, you pH is dangerously low, as Jack of Hearts said. smile.gif You need to raise your pH first. You can do this with baking soda. I'm quoting Ranchugirl's directions on this, since I haven't yet stored it to memory. rolleyes.gif

"I would start with 1 teaspoon, and test the water after 30 minutes to an hour. Keep on putting 1 teaspoon at the time in until you see a rise in the pH. Slower is better here, any major swing in pH can cause stress. Up isn't as bad as down, yet still needs to be done gradually."
I would think that you'd dissolve it in some tank water before adding to the tank.

Good luck and keep us posted.

Debbie
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.