Thanks, guys! Tammy - did you see the few Ryukin babies that were in with the Phoenix fry in the kitchen? The "polkadot" black/white ones? Those were the original Clementine/Freckles cross that was "accidental".
Nearly every one has impressive body conformation and most have pretty nice looking broadtails - even though Freckles is not a broadtail (Longtail instead) he is breeding pretty nicely - a good match for Clementine.
I have waaaaay too many tanks of fry. (I am looking to pick up some more tanks where Tammy found her new one) I cull heavily. I am getting, slowly, to the point where I have to start culling simply for what I may want. There are so many from that particular breeding that are borderline fish - nice petshop quality, I guess, but I have no time or space for them. And there are soooo many that may be fairly good standard tail or even short tail ryukins, but I am after the broadtail ones.... so I may have to hold my breath, grit my teeth and cull those, too. I have no space to raise them even to the size needed for the petshop. I would rather give the water and time to more promising broadtails.
I am quickly reaching the stage where the fry must meet the criteria of:
1. Do I, personally, want that fish?
2. Will I, personally, show that fish?
3. Do I think I could win with that particular fish?
4. Is there anything else about that particular fish that makes me believe that it will grow into the kind of fish that would satisfy the first three questions?
If the answer is no to any of those first three questions and no to the forth, the fry goes.

I think I will still have a good many really nice fry that fit all those criteria well - more than enough to share with my friends, when all is said and done.
(The new tank of eggs/fry now has soooo many tiny thread sized fry fastened to the glass that I can barely see any open glass. They are going to need something far larger than a 10 gallon tank as soon as they are free swimming!

)