Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Sand Substrate
Forum > The Goldfish Topics > Goldfish Tanks > Goldfish plants, & how to set up a planted tank
KoiGuy
What is a cheap & good kind of Sand for goldfish & plants?

1) playground sand – may cause cancer

2) all purpose sand – may cause cancer
may contain silicates & harmful dust

3) patio sand fine

4) patio sand coarse – may cause cancer
Sushi67
Most plants don't even like sand. Its mostly used as accents in tanks. Goldfish also don't do so well with sand. I would recommend gravel or those tiny pebbles.

ADA sand is a little pricey but its the best. Besides that I've heard a popular choice is playground sand. Make sure it has no chemicals added and that it isn't calcium carbonate.
touchofsky
Most often substrates such as Flourite are used in planted tanks smile.gif
KoiGuy
yeah, I want some inexpensive sand on top
and I think there are more choices for the richer bottom layer
aqua
I wouldn't recommend using sand for goldfish. Keep in mind that if you use sand as a top layer and something gravel-like as a bottom layer, the larger particles will eventually work their way up and end up on top.
KoiGuy
I think lots of people use sand with GF successfully
Nenn
I don't know about the plants, but I hear very coarse sand is fine in goldfish setups. However, I'm not very familiar with the sand you've listed, so I don't know which is best.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.