Can water conditioner, Aquasafe to be specific, go bad? I recently got my aunts old tank set up that she hasnt used in about 5 years and it came with the water conditioner. I opened it and it didn't smell like the one that i had, it was stinky and smelled like fish. Strong fish. I was scared to use it, then I acciedentaly grabbed it and ended up puting it in my new tank water. I didn't catch it till I had gone to put it away. The fish seem fine, I added my own to the tank as soon as I realize it.