QUOTE(jkamillr @ Apr 1 2006, 11:57 AM)
If it were a water quality issue wouldn't the black moor have the same reaction?
[right][snapback]502938[/snapback][/right]
Maybe and maybe not. Some fish have stronger immune systems than others. However, it's only a matter of time b/4 the moor has issues as well.
Unfortunately, you guys are overstocked. Fancy goldfish require 10 gallons of water each. Therefore, you are short at least 15 gallons of water. Is it possible for you to upgrade to a 20g with an adequate filter to handle the load? That would greatly help your fish.
When a tank is set up, it should go through a "cycle". Here is an excellent link for your review.
http://www.kokosgoldfish.com/cycle.htmlHow often does your husband "clean-out" your tank?
We need to know what your water parameters are:
ammonia
nitrIte
nitrAte
pH
If you don't have any test kits, you can take a sample of your water to the fish store and they can test it for you.
You want your ammonia to be 0; your nitrItes to be 0; and your nitrAtes to be less than 20.
And in order to achieve these #s, your tank needs to be cycled.
Your other alternative is to perform 100% water changes on a daily basis to keep your ammo and nitrItes to 0.