Your water comes from 2 sources. the salt river project and from 13 wells. They use ozone and chlorine to disinfect the water and filter it thru activated carbon. they also add caustic soda which is probably soda ash which is a buffer. Several of the wells will exceed the new standards for arsenic but overall the water doesn't exceed the new standard. I can't tell from their diagram where the well water comes into the system. My city has a similar thing going on with several wells and as I understand it, the well water goes directly into the distribution system rather than thru the water treatment plant, so our water varies somewhat depending on where you live in town.
These are the Metal Safe Limit levels as defined in the Textbook of Fish Health:
Your highest value - toxicity info
.0051ppm - Copper 0.014mg/l More toxic in soft water; Zinc exacerbates toxicity; Combined both are dangerous;
Zinc 0.01mg/l Synergistic with copper; 0.15mg/l In hard Water;
Cadmium 0.03mg/l;
.02ppm - Chromium 0.10mg/l;
.001 - Lead 0.01mg/l In soft Water; 4.00mg/l In hard Water;
Silver 0.03mg/l
(mg/l is the same as ppm).
From another source:
.0616ppm - The 50% kill in 48 hours for carp for chloroform (TriHaloMethanes or THMs) is 162 ppm.
Those look ok, tho copper is about half the the toxic level. What's your water hardness (GH)?
These are also nasties, but I don't have any toxicity info on them: Bromodichloromethane
Bromoform
Chloroform
Chloromethane
Dibromochloromethane
You might check
here and see if carbon adsorbs any of those.
Of the monthly samples taken 3.2% tested positive for coliform bacteria. but no fecal coliforms were detected. coliform bacteria are an indicator of bacterial contamination in the water. There is also some radioactivity happening too, but again, I don't know how much is a problem.
Your alkalinity (KH) ranged from 40-130ppm. Wow! wide range... Keep an eye on it.
Ph ranged from 6.8 to 7.8. Wow! wide range... Keep an eye on it.
Chloride ranged from 140-440ppm. (Chloride is a major player in osmoregulation and protects against nitrIte poisoning).
13.5 gr/gallon = 231ppm calcium or about 13dh carbonate hardness number. Great for goldies and plenty to keep copper and zinc from being as toxic. Any idea what range bettas like?
nitrAte ranged from 0.65 - 7.90ppm
So are you using water from the water softener?
Are you adding anything to replace the minerals removed by the softener?
What are you water test readings from that?