what color is your algae? lush and green? icky and brown? black, red, blue? the latter can be bad. most commonly youll have green or brown. green and brown are actually quite beneficial to your fish. they are in fact living plants, and eat nitrates, and also can be a snack for your goldies. i would regularly see mine munching on the walls when i had thick algae growth. if you wanted a pleco, make sure you get a rubber nose, bristle nose, or bushy nose. they eat algae well, and do no harm to goldfish. common plecos, however will suck themselves to your fish and suck off their slime coat, if given the opportunity. algae is basically an asthetic thing, if you like it, leave it, if you dont, scrape it.