ok, the story is, blaze and guinness are spawning so i decided to handspawn them properly this time. put them in the shoe box one at a time, decided to put shadow in just on the offchance she may have some eggs for me. anyway, i squeezed her gently and out came some milt! i was sure she was a female, she/he/it has had an outy ever since i got her/him/it nearly a year ago and there are no breeding stars. what the22!? im so confuuuuuused!

hmmm. I've had a few goldies that have given me some sexing problems. Sometimes I think they're girls, sometimes I think they're boys.

Good for you on your attempts to handspawn. That's pretty impressive!!

Wow I didn't even think you could handspawn goldfish, I mean I've seen um do it to salmon, I just never put two and two together
This is why I don't even bother with sexing my goldfish (My only aquarium is a pond). Although I believe I will try once they get larger.
Good Luck with your breeding attempt.