Once I scrape it off it doesn't grow back anything like it used to, and what does grow back is much thinner and lighter. I added marine activated carbon in pantyhose to the sump, and also figured out how to keep the protein skimmer working right (the water level in the sump was too high).
I ended up getting an Engineer Goby and he's doing great. He is sooo cool to watch. He has tunnels all over in the sand and little holes where he comes out. He is causing the live rock to sink though- I'm hoping it won't be a problem. I was a little concerned that the rock might collapse on him and kill him but the pet store guy said it's possible but unlikely. Hopefully that won't happen.
I think my next purchase will be a lawnmower blenny. I don't think I'm going to need as big a clean up crew as I thought, now that the algea is slowly losing the battle. Oh, I also decreased the photo-period of the tank from 12 hours to ten hours for now.
I was so excited I just had to post about it. Hopefully the algea doesn't have an explosive bloom now because I jinxed myself.